Cheesy Chicken Broccoli Orzo

Cheesy Chicken Broccoli Orzo is the ultimate weeknight dinner that brings comfort and flavor together in one skillet! With tender chicken, vibrant broccoli, creamy melted cheese, and perfectly cooked orzo, this dish is pure cozy deliciousness that your whole family will devour.

Love More Chicken Recipes? Try My Chicken with Mashed Potatoes or this Chicken and Spinach Casserole next.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

This Cheesy Chicken Broccoli Orzo is everything you want in a weeknight meal. It’s creamy without being heavy, packed with protein and veggies, and comes together in about 30 minutes. No separate pots for pasta, no complicated steps—just straightforward cooking that delivers restaurant-quality flavor right from your stovetop.

Print

Ingredient List

For the Chicken:

• 1 tablespoon oil
• 1 lb chicken breast, cut into bite-size pieces
• 1 teaspoon salt
• 1 teaspoon pepper

For the Orzo:

• 2 tablespoons butter
• ½ onion, finely diced
• 4 garlic cloves, minced
• 1½ cups broccoli florets, cut into small pieces
• 1 cup orzo pasta (dry)
• 3 cups chicken broth
• 1½ cups cheese (½ cup Parmesan + 1 cup cheddar)
• 1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice

For Topping (Optional):

• Fresh herbs (basil, oregano, or parsley)
• Extra freshly grated Parmesan

Why These Ingredients Work

Chicken breast is just what I usually have in my freezer because Costco. Thighs work great too and they’re juicier. I cut everything small so my kids don’t need knives and also it cooks faster.

Orzo pasta looks like rice had a baby with pasta and I’m obsessed. It cooks directly in the broth which means flavor gets absorbed into every piece instead of just sitting on top. Plus while it cooks it releases this starch that makes everything thick and creamy without adding flour or anything fancy. It just does it.

Broccoli florets are my attempt at being a parent who feeds vegetables to their children. When they’re drowning in cheese sauce even I get excited about eating them. Just cut them smaller than you think—like way smaller—or they’ll still be crunchy when everything else is done.

Chicken broth is where all the flavor comes from so don’t even think about using water. I tried that once thinking “how different can it be?” Very different. Very bad different. Use broth.

Parmesan and cheddar cheese are the dream team here. Parmesan’s got that sharp salty nutty thing happening and cheddar is gooey and comforting and makes my kids actually eat dinner without complaining. Together? Magic.

Fresh lemon juice sounds like something from a fancy cooking show but it’s literally just squeezing half a lemon. Without it everything tastes heavy and flat. With it? Everything wakes up. One tablespoon changes the whole game.

Butter and aromatics is just a pretentious way of saying onions and garlic cooked in butter. This is where your house starts smelling good enough that your teenagers actually come out of their rooms.

Essential Tools and Equipment

• Large skillet or sauté pan with a lid (mine’s 12 inches and works perfect)
• Sharp knife and cutting board
• Wooden spoon or spatula
• Measuring cups and spoons
• Plate for resting the chicken
• Box grater for the cheese (because we’re doing this right)

How To Make Cheesy Chicken Broccoli Orzo

Step 1: Cook the Chicken

Put your skillet on medium-high heat and add the oil. While that’s heating up, dump salt and pepper all over your chicken pieces. Don’t be precious about it—get both sides. When the oil starts looking wavy and shimmery (that’s your signal it’s hot enough), add the chicken in a single layer.

Now comes the hard part where you have to just leave it alone for three entire minutes. I know. I KNOW. You want to flip it and poke it and move it around. Don’t. Walk away. Check TikTok. Whatever. You need that golden crust. After three minutes flip it all over and cook another three minutes till it’s not pink anymore. Pull everything onto a plate and throw some foil over it to keep it warm.

Step 2: Sauté the Aromatics

Don’t you dare wash that pan. All those crusty brown bits stuck to the bottom? That’s literally flavor you already paid for. Throw in your butter and chopped onion and turn the heat down to medium. Let this cook for like five to seven minutes, stirring every now and then, until the onion gets soft and translucent.

Add your garlic and cook for one more minute. Not two. Not three. ONE. Because garlic goes from perfect to burnt and bitter in like fifteen seconds. Right about now your kitchen smells so good that everyone starts wandering in asking when food will be ready.

Step 3: Add the Broccoli

Dump in the broccoli and mix it around with everything. Let it cook for two or three minutes until it starts getting tender and turns that bright almost neon green. This gives it a head start so it’s not still raw and crunchy when everything else is done.

Step 4: Toast the Orzo

Add your dry orzo straight into the pan and stir it around for about a minute. This toasts it slightly and wakes up the flavor. Seems small but I noticed the difference once I started doing this step.

Step 5: Simmer with Broth

Pour in all the chicken broth and grab your wooden spoon and scrape up all those brown bits from the bottom. Get aggressive with it. That’s where the good stuff lives. Let everything come up to a simmer then dial your heat down to medium-low.

Okay here’s where you need to stay in the kitchen. Set a timer for ten minutes and stir every two or three minutes. Orzo will stick and burn if you ignore it. I know because I’ve done it twice—once while folding laundry and once while helping with math homework. When it’s done most of the liquid should be gone but you want it still kinda saucy not dry.

Step 6: Add Cheese and Chicken

TAKE THE PAN OFF THE HEAT. I’m saying this in caps because this is where everyone messes up and ends up with grainy broken sauce. If the pan’s too hot the cheese freaks out and gets all weird. Take it off the burner, wait like thirty seconds, THEN stir in your Parmesan and cheddar till it all melts together smooth.

Add your chicken back in with whatever juices are on the plate. Mix everything till the chicken’s warmed through.

Step 7: Finish and Serve

Squeeze in the lemon juice and stir one last time. Taste it—need more salt? Fix it now. More pepper? Do it. Throw some herbs on top if you have any (I usually have parsley growing in a pot that’s barely hanging on) and extra Parmesan if you’re feeling fancy. Get it on the table while it’s hot.

You Must Know

Stir the orzo or suffer. You gotta stay there and stir every couple minutes. Set alarms on your phone if you have to. Walk away and you’ll come back to half of it stuck to the bottom of your pan. Been there. Scrubbed that.

Turn off the heat before cheese goes anywhere near this pan. Hot pan plus cheese equals grainy gross separated sauce that looks like it curdled. Let it cool down for like thirty seconds then add cheese. That’s literally all you need to do.

The lemon juice is mandatory. I skipped it the first time I made this thinking “who’s gonna notice?” Me. I noticed. The whole thing tasted flat and heavy. Made it again with the lemon and literally said “OH” out loud in my kitchen. It’s transformative.

Personal Secret: I always make extra orzo on the side—like half a cup—and keep it in a little container in my fridge. When I reheat leftovers and they’ve gotten super thick overnight (because orzo’s like a sponge), I just dump in some of that fresh orzo with a splash of broth and suddenly it looks like I just made it fresh. Figured this out by accident and now I do it every single time.

Pro Tips & Cooking Hacks

Grate your cheese from a block or accept mediocrity. I sound crazy about this but it MATTERS. Pre-shredded cheese has cellulose powder coating it to keep it from sticking in the bag. That same powder stops it from melting smoothly. I fought with grainy sauce for weeks before someone on Reddit told me this. Now I grate my own and it’s perfect every time.

Broccoli smaller than you think. Like quarter-size florets. Maybe smaller. They need to cook at exactly the same speed as the orzo or you end up with crunchy broccoli in soft pasta and that’s just wrong.

Stay nearby during simmering. Orzo has this annoying thing where it goes from perfect to complete mush in about ninety seconds. I start checking at nine minutes and don’t go far.

Have backup broth ready. Sometimes the orzo drinks up liquid faster than you expect. Keep another half cup nearby so you can add it if things get too thick before the pasta’s actually cooked.

Hot pan for chicken is key. Medium-high heat and then don’t touch it for three full minutes. Let it build that crust. That’s flavor.

Frozen broccoli PSA: If you’re using frozen you MUST thaw it and squeeze out the water first. Like really squeeze it. Otherwise it’s basically a water bomb that makes your whole dish watery and sad. Learned this the hard way on a night my in-laws were over. Embarrassing.

Flavor Variations & Suggestions

Spicy version: Red pepper flakes when you cook the garlic. Or just put hot sauce on the table. My husband drowns his in Cholula every time.

Italian style: Mozzarella instead of cheddar, sun-dried tomatoes thrown in with the broccoli, fresh basil at the end. Completely different dinner.

Southwest thing: Pepper jack cheese, canned black beans (drained obviously), cumin and chili powder. My friend Ashley makes it this way and refuses to try my version because she’s convinced hers is better. (It’s not but don’t tell her.)

More vegetables: Mushrooms, spinach, cherry tomatoes cut in half, frozen peas. Whatever’s in your fridge. Add them in the last few minutes.

Different cheese: Smoked cheddar makes it taste expensive without doing extra work. Gruyère if you’re trying to impress somebody. Monterey Jack if you want it extra melty.

Protein swaps: Shrimp cooks in like three minutes so just toss them in at the end. Italian sausage is amazing. Or skip meat completely and load up on vegetables—I’ve done this when my vegetarian sister visits.

Lighter but still good: Half the cheese, stir in Greek yogurt at the end. Still creamy, less heavy, you feel slightly less guilty about seconds.

Make-Ahead Options

Sunday prep life: Every Sunday I chop everything—chicken, broccoli, onion, garlic—and stick it all in separate containers in my fridge. Monday through Wednesday I just pull them out and dump as I go. Cuts cooking time basically in half.

Leftovers situation: Keeps in the fridge for three to four days easy. The orzo soaks up liquid as it sits so it gets really thick and almost solid. When you reheat just add some broth or milk to thin it back out. Low heat on the stove, keep stirring.

Freezing real talk: Cheese sauce doesn’t freeze great. It can separate and get kinda grainy when you thaw it. But I’ve frozen it anyway when I made too much and it still tastes good even if the texture’s slightly off. Cool it completely, good freezer containers, two months max. Thaw overnight in the fridge, reheat with extra broth, stir constantly.

Meal prep for the week: Double batch on Sunday, portion into five containers, lunch is handled. Reheats perfect in the microwave if you add a little liquid and cover it with a paper towel.

Recipe Notes & Baker’s Tips

About that broth: Use good broth because you’re cooking pasta directly in it. Cheap flavorless broth equals bland pasta. I go for low-sodium so I can control salt myself because some broths are crazy salty.

No orzo at the store? Small shells work. Ditalini. Even broken-up spaghetti. Just check the package for cook time because it might be different.

Rotisserie chicken is my cheat code. I use it probably half the time. One chicken from Costco, shred about two cups, add it when you’d normally return the cooked chicken. Saves ten minutes and honestly tastes the same.

Lemon at the end not the beginning: Heat makes citrus taste bitter. Fresh squeeze at the finish keeps it bright and fresh tasting.

Too soupy? Orzo’s done but there’s still a bunch of liquid? Just simmer uncovered for another couple minutes. Extra liquid evaporates, starch from the pasta thickens everything naturally.

Serving Suggestions

This is honestly a full meal by itself but sometimes I throw together a super basic salad to make myself feel like a functional adult. Just lettuce, tomatoes, whatever dressing’s in the fridge. Or garlic bread if I remembered to buy it (or if there’s frozen garlic bread which totally counts).

Sometimes I roast asparagus or green beans if I’m already using the oven for something else. Or I’ll just slice cucumbers and tomatoes and call it a side dish. Very low effort stuff.

Extra Parmesan on the table always. Whatever herbs are still alive in my garden (usually just parsley at this point). Pepper grinder. Sometimes I drizzle olive oil over mine because I saw someone do that on Instagram and it’s actually really good.

How to Store Your Cheesy Chicken Broccoli Orzo

Fridge life: Airtight container, three to four days. Fair warning it gets really thick as it sits because the orzo keeps absorbing sauce like a little sponge.

Reheating: Add like a quarter cup of broth or milk per serving before heating. Stovetop’s best—medium-low heat, keep stirring or it’ll stick. Microwave works too—add liquid, cover with a paper towel, one minute at a time, stir between.

Freezer: Cool it completely first, freezer containers or zip bags with air squeezed out, two months tops. Thaw in the fridge overnight. The sauce might look separated when you thaw it but tastes fine once you reheat and stir.

Room temp: Get it in the fridge within two hours. One hour if it’s summer and your AC’s broken like mine was last July.

Allergy Information

What’s in this:

• Dairy (butter, Parmesan, cheddar)
• Gluten (orzo pasta)

How to deal with it:

No dairy? Use olive oil instead of butter. Dairy-free cheese or nutritional yeast for that cheesy taste. Cashew cream mixed with dairy-free cheese shreds works pretty well. Won’t be identical but still decent.

No gluten? They make gluten-free orzo now—Barilla has one, I’ve seen Jovial brand too. Or just use any small gluten-free pasta you can find. Follow whatever the package says for timing.

Nut allergies: No nuts in this. But check your broth and cheese labels if allergies are serious because sometimes factories process multiple things.

Egg allergies: Zero eggs in here so you’re good.

Questions I Get Asked A Lot

Can I use frozen broccoli instead of fresh?

Yeah but thaw it first and squeeze out ALL the water. Like really wring it out. Frozen broccoli holds so much water and if you just dump it in frozen your whole dish gets watery. Been there. It was sad. Thaw it, dry it, add it in the last five minutes instead of when you’d add fresh.

My sauce turned out grainy instead of creamy. What happened?

Pan was too hot when you added cheese. The cheese proteins basically have a panic attack and seize up. Next time take the pan completely off the heat, count to thirty, THEN add cheese while stirring. Also make sure you’re grating your own cheese from a block not using pre-shredded.

The orzo’s cooked but my sauce is too thin. How do I fix it?

Keep simmering uncovered for another two to three minutes, stirring constantly. Extra liquid cooks off and the starch from the orzo thickens everything naturally. Or dump in another tablespoon of Parmesan which also helps thicken.

💬 Made this? Tell me how it went! Did your kids actually eat vegetables? Did you burn the bottom like I did that one time? What’d you change? Drop a comment and let me know!