Valentine’s Day Oreo Pops

Valentine’s Day Oreo Pops are simple, adorable, and totally irresistible! With just Oreo cookies, colorful candy melts, festive sprinkles, and lollipop sticks, you can create these impressive treats in minutes. They’re perfect for classroom parties, Valentine’s exchanges, or just because you want something sweet and fun to share with the people you love.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

Fun, festive, and delightfully sweet, Valentine’s Day Oreo Pops are the perfect treat to share with someone you love. Chocolate-dipped Oreos decorated with colorful sprinkles and hearts make a cute and easy dessert that’s sure to spread smiles and love with every bite.

Print

Ingredient List

Main Ingredients:

• Oreo Cookies (buy the family pack—you’ll want extras)
• 4-inch lollipop sticks
• Candy melts in red, bright pink, and bright white (one bag does about 12 cookies)
• Sprinkles: hearts in different sizes, sugar pearls, whatever catches your eye

Tools You’ll Need:

• 3 coffee mugs or microwave-safe bowls
• Piping bag if you want to get fancy (totally optional)
• Parchment paper

Substitution Notes:

• No candy melts at the store? Grab almond bark from the baking aisle or use chocolate chips mixed with a little coconut oil.
• Out of heart sprinkles? I’ve used literally everything—crushed candy canes, rainbow jimmies, even those little star sprinkles from my pantry. All looked cute.
• Different Oreos? The mint ones are incredible. Golden Oreos give you that vanilla vibe. Even the weird birthday cake flavor works.

Why These Ingredients Work

Oreo Cookies are basically indestructible. You can stick things through them, dunk them in hot melted candy, and they hold up perfectly. Plus everybody already loves them, so you’re starting with a win.

Candy Melts changed my life when I discovered them at the craft store. They melt smooth without burning, they dry fast, and you don’t need a culinary degree to work with them. Way less fussy than tempering real chocolate, which I’ve tried exactly once and never again.

Lollipop Sticks make everything more fun. Kids lose their minds over food on sticks. My son literally ate vegetables once because they were on a stick. The power is real.

Festive Sprinkles are honestly just for looks, but they make these go from “oh that’s nice” to “WHERE DID YOU GET THESE?!” I buy bags of seasonal sprinkles whenever they go on clearance and hoard them like a dragon.

Essential Tools and Equipment

Honestly you probably have everything already:

• Coffee mugs for melting the candy—I use my regular everyday mugs
• Parchment paper because if you use regular paper, it’ll stick and you’ll be sad
• Lollipop sticks from the craft store or Amazon
• Your microwave

If You Want to Be Extra:

• Piping bag for drizzling designs on top
• Styrofoam block to stick the pops in while they dry—though I just lay mine flat on the counter

How To Make Valentine’s Day Oreo Pops

Step 1: Separate Your Oreos

Twist apart all your Oreos and lay them out on the counter. Some will break—that’s fine, those are your snacks. My kids fight over who gets to eat the broken ones, so sometimes I “accidentally” break a few extra.

Get all your separating done before you start melting anything. Makes the whole process way faster.

Step 2: Attach the Lollipop Sticks

Melt a handful of candy melts in twenty-second bursts. Stir between each round. Takes maybe a minute total. You just need enough to act as glue.

Dip your stick about halfway into the melted candy, then sandwich it between the cookie halves. Push together gently so you don’t crack the cookies. I learned that lesson when my first three split in half.

Do this for every cookie before moving forward. Line them up like little soldiers on your counter.

Step 3: Let the Sticks Set

Walk away. Go check your email. Start a load of dishes. Just leave them alone for ten minutes while the candy hardens.

I know it’s tempting to keep going, but if you rush this, your cookies will slide off the sticks when you dip them. I’ve watched it happen to my sister three times because she won’t listen to me.

If you’re impatient: Five minutes in the freezer works. Set a timer so you don’t forget them.

Step 4: Melt Your Coating Candy

Fill your mug two-thirds with red candy melts. Microwave twenty seconds, stir hard. Another twenty seconds, stir again. Keep going until it’s completely smooth.

The candy should look shiny and pourable, kind of like really thick cream. If it looks clumpy, keep heating. If it looks grainy or weird, water probably got in—dump it and start fresh.

Step 5: Dip and Coat Your Oreo Pops

Grab a cookie by its stick and dunk it straight into the candy. Cover the whole thing. Pull it out slow and let the extra drip back in. I tap the stick on the rim a couple times to shake off excess.

Set it flat on parchment paper. If you see naked spots, spoon more candy over them quick before it sets.

Work at a decent pace because the candy starts hardening fast, especially if your kitchen’s cold. I learned this in January when mine were setting before I even got the sprinkles on.

Step 6: Add Your Sprinkles Right Away

Grab those sprinkles and dump them on while everything’s still wet and shiny. You’ve got maybe thirty seconds before the candy sets too much for sprinkles to stick.

I usually put a couple big hearts on, scatter some little ones, maybe add a few pearls. My daughter covers hers completely until you can’t see any candy. Both look good honestly.

Step 7: Repeat with Other Colors

Finish all your red ones first. Then melt your pink candy and do those. Then white. Or whatever order you feel like—there’s literally no wrong way.

Half an hour later you’ll have a whole batch that looks bakery-fancy, and you barely had to think about it.

You Must Know

Twenty-second intervals are your friend. Candy melts burn easier than you think, and once they’re burned, they’re trash. I’ve ruined whole bags by getting impatient and microwaving too long.

Don’t skip the stick-setting time. Every single person who’s ever complained to me about cookies falling off skipped this step. Every. Single. One.

One color at a time, especially your first time. Trying to juggle three cups of melted candy while you’re learning is a recipe for frustration. Focus on one, finish it, move to the next.

Personal Secret: I flip my Oreo upside down after dipping and hold it there for five seconds before laying it down. The candy coating drips smooth instead of pooling at the bottom, and suddenly your homemade pops look professional. Nobody ever believes I made them in my regular kitchen.

Pro Tips & Cooking Hacks

Candy too thick to dip smoothly? Stir in half a teaspoon of vegetable oil. Magic fix.

Candy hardened in your cup while you were working? Reheat for ten seconds. You can do this over and over—I’ve reheated the same candy five times.

Want easy cleanup? Do all this on a big baking sheet lined with parchment. Everything stays contained, and you can just toss the parchment when you’re done.

Making these with kids? They handle sprinkles. You handle hot melted candy. Everyone’s happy, nobody gets burned.

Wanna look fancy? After your base coat dries completely, melt a different color, cut the corner off a sandwich bag, and drizzle zigzags on top. Takes two extra minutes and everyone thinks you’re Martha Stewart.

Flavor Variations / Suggestions

Different Cookie Bases:

• Golden Oreos taste like the fancy vanilla ones from bakeries
• Mint Oreos with chocolate coating are dangerously good
• Peanut Butter Oreos—my husband requests these specifically now

Other Holiday Colors:

• Easter: Yellow, pink, purple, pastel everything
• Christmas: Red and green with those snowflake sprinkles
• Fourth of July: Red, white, blue with star sprinkles—we make these every summer
• Halloween: Orange and black, maybe add some gummy worms on top for creepy fun
• Birthdays: Whatever colors the person likes

Getting Fancy:

• White drizzle over pink looks incredibly elegant
• Add edible glitter because why not
• Stick a little fondant flower or heart on top before the candy sets
• Dip just half the cookie for a cool split color effect

Make Them Taste Different:

• Drop of peppermint extract in white candy makes them taste like those fancy chocolate mints
• Strawberry extract in pink candy (sounds weird, tastes amazing)
• Some candy melts come flavored already—vanilla, strawberry, even caramel

Make-Ahead Options

I actually prefer making these a few days early because then it’s one less thing I’m stressing about the morning of whatever event.

How Far Ahead: Two weeks easy, probably longer but mine get eaten before I find out.

Where to Keep Them: Room temperature in an airtight container. Put parchment between layers or they stick together. Don’t put them near a window or they’ll melt.

Freezing: They freeze perfectly for two months. Just make sure they’re sealed tight. Leave them out for twenty minutes before serving or they’ll sweat.

My Party Strategy: Three days before. They’re completely set, still look beautiful, and I’m not frantically making treats at midnight. Learned that lesson the hard way.

Recipe Notes & Baker’s Tips

Candy Melts vs Real Chocolate: Candy melts are easier and come in fun colors, but they taste more like sweet coating than rich chocolate. Real chocolate tastes better but you have to temper it properly or it’ll never harden right. I use candy melts because I’m lazy and they work.

My First Pop Always Looks Rough: I use my first one of each color to test if the candy’s the right consistency. It’s never my prettiest. Don’t get discouraged—the second one always looks better.

Parchment Paper Seriously Matters: I tried regular paper once when I ran out of parchment. It stuck so bad I had to throw away half my batch. Just use parchment or wax paper, I’m begging you.

Temperature Thing: If your Oreos are cold from the fridge, the hot candy coating will crack as it cools. Room temperature cookies work best. Just leave them on the counter while you get your stuff together.

Serving Suggestions

How to Show Them Off:

• Stick them in a pretty jar filled with those little conversation hearts
• Stack them on a cake stand for parties
• Wrap each one in a clear bag tied with ribbon—instant cute gifts
• Make a whole Valentine’s dessert spread with these as the star attraction

What Goes With Them:

• Fresh strawberries and chocolate-covered pretzels
• Add them to a dessert charcuterie board
• Set out with hot chocolate for a Valentine’s party
• Bring them to coffee dates (yes, really)

When to Make Them: School parties, Valentine’s exchanges, Galentine’s brunches, or just Tuesday afternoon because you want something cute.

Extra Touch: Tie little tags to the sticks that say “You’re Sweet” or “Be Mine”—my kids love doing this part.

How to Store Your Valentine’s Day Oreo Pops

Room Temperature: Keep them in an airtight container on your counter for two weeks. Put parchment between layers so they don’t stick.

Refrigerator: You can refrigerate them, but they’ll get condensation when you take them out and look all sweaty and sad. Not recommended.

Freezer: Up to two months frozen. Use an airtight container with parchment between layers. Let them thaw in the sealed container so they don’t get moisture on them.

For Gifting: Individual clear cellophane bags tied with ribbon keep them fresh about a week and look super cute.

Best Spot: Anywhere cool and dry. My pantry’s perfect. Just keep them away from heat and windows.

Allergy Information

What’s In These:

• Wheat (the Oreos)
• Soy (Oreos and candy melts)
• Milk (candy coating and Oreo filling)

Might Also Have: Check your specific candy melt and sprinkle brands for nuts and eggs.

Gluten-Free Version: Use gluten-free sandwich cookies. Glutino or Kinnikinnick brands taste good.

Dairy-Free Version: Enjoy Life makes dairy-free candy melts. Pair with dairy-free cookies and you’re set.

Vegan Version: Newman’s Own vegan sandwich cookies plus vegan candy melts work great.

Nut Concerns: No nuts in the actual recipe, but always check packaging if you’re dealing with serious allergies.

Questions I Get Asked A Lot

My candy melts are too thick to dip. Help?

Stir in half a teaspoon of vegetable oil. Or grab Paramount Crystals from the craft store—they’re made specifically for thinning candy. Don’t add water or milk, that ruins everything.

How do I stop the Oreos from falling off?

Dip the stick deep enough in the candy glue—about half an inch. Then actually wait for it to harden before dipping. That’s it. Those two things fix 99% of falling-off problems.

Why does my coating look streaky and gross?

Water got in somehow. Even one tiny drop makes candy seize up and look awful. Make sure everything’s bone dry, and don’t cover the candy while melting because steam drips down. If it happens, you gotta start over with fresh candy.

How long until they’re completely hard?

Fifteen to twenty minutes on the counter. Ten in the fridge. Five in the freezer. But if you refrigerate or freeze them, let them warm up in the sealed container first or the coating cracks.

💬 Made these? Tell me in the comments! Which color did you like best?