Simple and Comforting Mama’s Chicken Pie

Mama’s Chicken Pie is pure comfort in a baking dish—tender chicken swimming in creamy sauce, layered between buttery pie crust strips that bake up golden and flaky. No vegetables, no fuss, just straightforward deliciousness that even the pickiest eaters will devour!

Love More Chicken Pie Recipes? Try My Puff Pastry Chicken Pot Pie or this Red Lobster Biscuit Chicken Pot Pie next.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

A true comfort classic, this dish features tender chicken and creamy filling baked beneath a golden, buttery crust. Warm, hearty, and full of homestyle flavor, it’s the kind of meal that feels like a comforting hug from the kitchen.

Print

Ingredient List

For the Filling:

• 1 whole chicken or 3 large boneless chicken breasts
• 1 can cream of chicken soup (10.5 oz.)
• 1½ soup cans of chicken broth (use the empty soup can to measure—so easy!)
• ¼ tsp salt
• ½ tsp pepper

For the Crust Layers:

• 2 frozen 9″ pie crusts, thawed
• 2 Tbsp butter, divided

You’ll Also Need:

• Cooking spray for the baking dish

Why These Ingredients Work

The chicken is the star of the show, providing tender, juicy protein that soaks up all that creamy sauce. Using a whole chicken gives you the deepest flavor (plus you get that cooking liquid for soup later!), but boneless breasts work beautifully when you’re short on time.

Cream of chicken soup is the secret weapon here—it creates that velvety, nostalgic sauce without any complicated roux-making. I know some people turn their noses up at canned soup, but in this recipe? It’s PERFECT.

The chicken broth thins out the soup just enough to create a sauce that’s creamy but not gloppy. Using the soup can to measure means one less dish to wash—mama was smart like that!

Simple seasonings of salt and pepper let the chicken flavor shine through. This isn’t about fancy herbs and spices; it’s about comforting, familiar taste.

The pie crust strips are what make this recipe unique. Instead of a traditional top and bottom crust, the strips create layers that get crispy on the edges but soft and almost dumpling-like where they touch the filling. Pure genius!

Butter dots on each layer add richness and help the crust brown beautifully.

Essential Tools and Equipment

• Large pot for cooking the chicken
• 9×9 inch baking dish
• Mixing bowl
• Sharp knife or pizza cutter (for cutting crust strips)
• Spoon for spreading
• Cutting board

How To Make Mama’s Chicken Pie

Step 1: Cook Your Chicken

Place your whole chicken (or chicken breasts) in a large pot and cover with water. Bring to a boil, then reduce heat and simmer until the chicken is cooked through—about 45 minutes for a whole chicken, 20-25 minutes for breasts. Remove the chicken and let it cool until you can handle it. Chop the meat into bite-sized pieces and set aside.

Step 2: Mix Up the Creamy Filling

In a mixing bowl, combine the cream of chicken soup, chicken broth (measured using that empty soup can—1½ cans worth), salt, and pepper. Stir it up good until everything’s well combined. Add your chopped chicken and stir until every piece is coated in that creamy goodness.

Step 3: Start Building Your First Layer

Lightly spray your 9×9 baking dish with cooking spray. Spoon half of your chicken mixture into the bottom of the dish and spread it out evenly. Don’t worry about making it perfect—rustic is beautiful!

Step 4: Add the First Crust Layer

Now here’s where it gets fun! Take one of your thawed pie crusts and cut it into strips about 1 inch wide. You can use a knife or a pizza cutter—whatever feels comfortable. Lay these strips over your chicken mixture, covering it as completely as you can. It’s okay if there are little gaps; they’ll fill in as everything bakes. Dot the top of these strips with 1 tablespoon of butter, breaking it into small pieces and scattering them around.

Step 5: First Bake

Pop that dish into your preheated 400°F oven and bake for 25 minutes. The crust will start getting golden and the filling will be bubbling—it smells AMAZING at this point!

Step 6: Add Your Second Chicken Layer

Remove the dish from the oven (careful, it’s hot!). Spoon the remaining chicken mixture over the top of that first baked crust layer. Spread it out gently and evenly.

Step 7: Create Your Final Crust Layer

Cut your second pie crust into strips just like before. Now you can either simply lay them across the top, or if you’re feeling fancy, create a simple basket weave pattern—it’s easier than it looks and makes for a gorgeous presentation! Dot this layer with your remaining tablespoon of butter.

Step 8: Final Bake to Golden Perfection

Back into the oven it goes for another 25 minutes. You’re looking for that beautiful golden brown color on top and bubbling around the edges. When it comes out, let it sit for 5 minutes before serving.

You Must Know

The chicken MUST be fully cooled before chopping. Hot chicken will warm up your filling too much and make everything soupy. I learned this the hard way when I was too impatient and ended up with a runny mess!

Don’t skip the 5-minute rest after baking. I know you’re hungry, but this brief wait time lets the sauce thicken up and makes serving so much easier. Plus, it keeps you from burning your tongue on molten filling!

Personal Secret: I always use the chicken broth that comes from cooking the chicken itself instead of store-bought when I’m using a whole chicken. Just strain it, let it cool, and measure out what you need.

Pro Tips & Cooking Hacks

Rotisserie chicken shortcut: Stop by the grocery store and grab a rotisserie chicken. You’ll save 45 minutes of cooking time, and honestly? The flavor is fantastic. Just remove the skin and shred the meat.

Leftover turkey magic: This recipe is INCREDIBLE with leftover Thanksgiving turkey. I make it every year the weekend after Thanksgiving, and my family looks forward to it as much as the turkey dinner itself!

Perfect strip width: Cut your strips about 1 inch wide. Thinner strips get too crispy, thicker strips stay doughy in the middle.

The butter matters: Don’t skip dotting with butter or use margarine instead. Real butter creates that golden, flaky top that makes this dish special.

Common mistake to avoid: Don’t make your filling too thick. If your cream of chicken soup is one of those “extra thick” varieties, add a splash more broth. The sauce should be pourable, not gloppy.

Flavor Variations & Suggestions

Herbed version: Add ½ teaspoon of dried thyme or poultry seasoning to the filling for a more traditional pot pie flavor.

Garlic lovers: Stir in ½ teaspoon of garlic powder to the filling mixture.

Richer version: Use cream of mushroom soup instead of cream of chicken, or do half and half!

Add some vegetables (if you must!): While the original recipe’s simplicity is its charm, you can stir in 1 cup of frozen peas or diced carrots if you want to sneak in some veggies. Just don’t tell the purists I told you that!

Biscuit-style topping: Instead of pie crust strips on the final layer, drop spoonfuls of refrigerated biscuit dough on top for a different texture.

Make-Ahead Options

This is such a practical recipe for busy families! Here’s how to prep ahead:

The filling: You can cook the chicken and make the entire filling mixture up to 2 days in advance. Store it covered in the refrigerator, then proceed with assembly when you’re ready to bake.

Complete assembly: You can assemble the entire dish (through the first layer of crust) and refrigerate for up to 24 hours before baking. Just add 5-10 minutes to your first baking time since it’ll be starting cold.

Freezer-friendly: Assemble the entire dish but don’t bake it. Cover tightly with plastic wrap and then aluminum foil. Freeze for up to 3 months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator before baking as directed. You might need to add 10 extra minutes to the cooking time.

Batch cooking: Double this recipe and freeze one for later. Future you will thank present you when dinner is already done!

Recipe Notes & Baker’s Tips

The layering technique is what sets this apart from regular chicken pot pie. Those middle crust strips get wonderfully soft and almost dumpling-like where they touch the filling, while the edges stay crispy. It’s the best of both worlds!

If your pie crusts are the kind that come rolled up in a box rather than in a foil pan, that works perfectly too. Just unroll them and proceed with cutting into strips.

The 9×9 pan is really the ideal size for this recipe. An 8×8 will be too small and overflow, and a 9×13 will spread everything too thin. If you only have a 9×13, consider making 1½ times the recipe.

Don’t worry if your crust strips don’t cover the filling perfectly—gaps are fine! Everything melds together beautifully as it bakes.

Serving Suggestions

This pie is a complete meal on its own, but I love serving it with:

• A simple green salad with ranch dressing to add some freshness
• Cranberry sauce on the side—the sweet-tart contrast is incredible
• Roasted green beans with a little garlic butter
• Buttermilk biscuits (yes, MORE carbs, but sometimes you just need it!)
• Homemade applesauce for a slightly sweet side

For presentation, I like to cut it into squares and use a pie server to lift each portion out. Garnish with a sprinkle of fresh parsley or a crack of black pepper if you want to fancy it up.

This is perfect for Sunday dinners, potlucks (it travels well!), or when you need to bring a meal to a friend. It reheats beautifully, so leftovers are actually exciting.

How to Store Your Mama’s Chicken Pie

Room temperature: Don’t leave this pie out for more than 2 hours. The creamy filling needs to be refrigerated.

In the refrigerator: Cover the baking dish tightly with aluminum foil or transfer portions to an airtight container. It’ll keep for 3-4 days.

In the freezer: Freeze in individual portions in freezer-safe containers for up to 3 months. Make sure to cool completely before freezing.

Reheating instructions:

• Microwave individual portions for 2-3 minutes until heated through
• For oven reheating (best for maintaining crust texture): Cover with foil and bake at 350°F for 20-25 minutes until hot
• From frozen: Let thaw overnight in the fridge, then reheat as directed above

Allergy Information

Contains: Wheat (pie crust), dairy (butter, cream soup), chicken

Gluten-free option: Use gluten-free pie crusts and gluten-free cream of chicken soup (Pacific Foods makes a good one).

Dairy-free option: Use dairy-free pie crusts (many store-bought crusts are actually dairy-free—check labels!), substitute the butter with dairy-free butter or oil, and use dairy-free cream of chicken soup or make your own with dairy-free milk and cornstarch.

Low-sodium version: Use low-sodium cream of chicken soup and low-sodium broth, and omit the added salt.

Questions I Get Asked A Lot

My filling seems too thick/too thin. What do I do?

If it’s too thick, add a splash more chicken broth—2-3 tablespoons at a time—until it’s pourable but not watery. If it’s too thin, whisk in a tablespoon of flour or cornstarch mixed with a little cold water and let it sit for 5 minutes to thicken.

Do the pie crusts need to be completely thawed?

Yes! If they’re still frozen or even partially frozen, they’ll be too hard to cut into strips and won’t bake evenly with the filling.

Why do we bake it in two stages instead of all at once?

Great question! Baking in stages ensures that middle crust layer gets perfectly cooked through. If you tried to do it all at once, you’d end up with either burnt top crust or raw middle crust. The two-stage method is the secret to getting everything just right!

💬 Tried this recipe? Leave a comment and rating below! I’d love to hear if this becomes a family favorite in your home like it is in mine!